Issue 114 - November 18 2004

 


Printer Friendly Version

Note: The size of the type may be changed by clicking on view at the top of your browser and selecting "text size". The document will print in the size you select.

The resignation of Secretary of State Colin Powell, was not unforeseen, but now allows us to access the job the way we’ve always seen it – now that his job is done. Of all of the “Neo-Cons,” War-Hawks, and Arch-Conservatives around George Du[m]byah’s table, Powell was often viewed as a “duck out of war,” a voice of moderation in a pool of ideological extremists. As a “War Man” and a lifelong soldier, he certainly had more credibility than any around the table, in terms of the “art of warfare,” but his advise was rarely followed on war issues. But it was his credibility as a diplomat that made him valuable to Bush. Powell was the ultimate diplomat, a man viewed as reasonable by the rest of the world at a time when the United States came to be seen as hardline unilateralist. It was Powell that most frequently fought with neo-cons Cheney, Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz, who saw war more of an economic opportunity than a case for defense of our ideas. All Powell could do was buy Iraq time. The war was a foregone conclusion. All Bush needed was somebody to sell the idea. Because of their various motives and agendas that conflicted with America’s truer interests, none of the neo-cons could have sold this War on Iraq as a defensible strategy in the fight against terrorism. But Powell could, and he did. That will be the lasting question on Powell’s legacy as the first African American Secretary of State: Was Colin Powell, and his credibility, used to start the War In Iraq?

Knowing what we know now, and knowing what Powell found out after the fact, the case could be made that he was used. Now, understand, we all give up something to get something else, so, in a sense, everybody uses everybody, and most of the time – we know this to be the case. Nobody is used who doesn’t want to be used. Very few people are used, unknowingly. Most just accept it as part of the territory, part of “the deal.” Powell, having “future ambitions,” played the role that he was given – as the moderate face of the party and the messenger of America’s foreign policy agenda. The message he ended up carrying for most of his term is one I’m sure he didn’t anticipate when he signed up for the job. But like most “good soldiers,” he kept to his commitment, even if he had to hold his nose all the while. It was a nasty job, but somebody had to do it. So the President sent Colin to sell the deal and Powell, thinking he had “the intelligence” to back up “the sell,” put his credibility on the line – and the United Nations reluctantly bought it, though no major governments were brought in other than (what the world press labeled as, America’s “lap dog”) Britain. Powell later found out that, not only were there no weapons of mass destruction, he was sent out with flawed intelligence and even to the post-report had flawed intelligence, all of which Powell was forced to admit. Powell, who became known as “the good and faithful soldier” of the administration, took the proverbial “bullet” for the administration while Cheney, then Rumsfeld hid in the shadows, and under Condi Rice’s skirt (figuratively), as their story unraveled before the 9/11 Commission. Iraq is seen as a failed policy and it was Powell who was forced to say it while Bush and the rest of the Neo-Cons remain in denial. Yes, Colin Powell was a good soldier, indeed.

Secretary of State is usually seen as “the rose” of U.S. cabinet position picks, but in the words of those famous hip-hop philosophers, Outkast, “when you lean a little bit closer, roses really smell like ‘doo, doo-doo’.” I’m sure that is part of the reason Powell is resigning. He got tired of the smell of this war, and you can only hold your nose for so long. It’s Powell that’s come up smelling like “doo, doo-doo.” I’m sure it’s going to take a few years to wash the “stank” out his nostrils so the smell won’t still be around for a possible presidential run in 2008. The best you can say about Powell’s tenure as Secretary of State was that he tried to keep his integrity intact, but it was a pretty “smelly” run. Particularly when you were used the way he was used, to start a war that the world knew was a sham from the outset. Colin Powell served his purpose for Bush – to finish the war that he (Powell) and Bush’s daddy didn’t finish in 1991. It’s still not finished, but it wasn’t because Powell didn’t try. He was “the messenger” in America’s misguided war message.

Anthony Asadullah Samad is a national columnist, author and managing director of the Urban Issues Forum. His upcoming book, 50 Years After Brown: The State of Black Equality In America is due out in 2004. He can be reached at www.AnthonySamad.com.

www.blackcommentator.com

Your comments are welcome.

Visit the Contact Us page for E-mail or Feedback.