For some Republicans, like Senator
Lindsey Graham (SC), the money in the $1.9 trillion stimulus bill
that is earmarked for black farmers and other socially disadvantaged
farmers is “reparations” and the indications are that he
is against reparations.
When,
at some time in the future, there is legislation that does address
reparations, more Republicans than Graham will come out of the
woodwork, because, if the nation is not careful, justice may be
perpetrated. We can’t have that, can we?
The
“American Rescue Plan,” the $1.9 trillion stimulus plan,
sets aside $5 billion for agriculture and about half of that will go
to black and other socially disadvantaged farmers. If that’s
reparations, it is less than a drop in the bucket to compensate for
the land that was stolen from black farmers throughout the 20th
Century. That theft was accomplished because of the rampant racism
that existed that allowed legal manipulation of black landowners and
the white supremacist dispensers of U.S. Department of Agriculture
funds at the local level, for generations.
In
short, the white local USDA committee members withheld money for
seeds and fertilizer for black farmers, until late in the growing
season. A black farmer might get the loan when the crops of the white
farmers all around were a foot high. There were other ways of
depriving farmers of color, but that’s an inkling of the
problem and it persisted for generations. It’s no wonder that
black farmers lost millions of acres of land in the last century. And
their numbers went from some 920,000 at the beginning of the century,
to about 17,000 in the mid-1980s. In 2021, the USDA says there are
nearly 45,000 black farmers. According to a report in The
Washington Post, black
farmers have lost 12 million acres in the last hundred years.
In
the last quarter of the 20th century, black farmers ramped up their
efforts to make the USDA own up to its failure (both major political
parties) to provide civil rights oversight, which allowed racism to
rule over the ownership of farmland, all across the South. Graham and
others like him have asked what compensation for black farmers has to
do with a Covid-19 bill. The simple answer is that, because the theft
of black-owned land and farms has occurred over generations, it was
made worse by the pandemic and, therefore, something had to be done
to help those who have been displaced by structural racism.
John
Boyd, president of the National Black Farmers Association, told
Yahoo!Finance, “(the bill is) a huge win for me and for Black
farmers.” He added, “I’ve been trying to get debt
relief through an act of Congress for about 30 years...it’s
been taken out of a lot of legislative efforts. This isn’t
something we just tried to do here recently. We’ve been trying
to do it for a very, very long time.”
A
Virginia crop and cattle farmer, Boyd pointed out, “We’ve
been totally excluded from all USDA subsidy programs like the Trump
payouts for the China trade war.” Boyd told Yahoo!Finance,
“Farmers of color, especially Black farmers, were virtually
absent from those monies. We didn’t get it. PPP, we didn’t
get it. We’re not getting farm operating loans, farm equipment
loans, or rural development loans, and this has been going on for
decades.” In 2020, USDA established the Coronavirus Food
Assistance Program (CFAP), to provide assistance to farmers affected
by the pandemic. Even so, the Environmental Working Group found that,
as of last October, about 97 percent of the $9.2 billion in CFAP
money went to white farmers, each receiving eight times more than the
average black farmer.
Graham
appeared on Fox News earlier this month and said during the
interview: “Let me give you an example of something that really
bothers me. In this bill, if you’re a farmer, your loan will be
forgiven up to 120 percent of your loan ... if you’re socially
disadvantaged, if you’re African American, some other minority.
But if you’re [a] white person, if you’re a white woman,
no forgiveness. That’s reparations. What does that have to do
with COVID?”
He
got an answer in a quick response from House Majority Whip James
Clyburn, (D-SC), who noted:
“Lindsey
Graham is from South Carolina. He knows South Carolina’s
history. He knows what the state of South Carolina and this country
has done to black farmers in South Carolina. They didn’t do it
to white farmers. We’re trying to rescue the lives and
livelihoods of people. He ought to be ashamed of himself.”
Whether
he considers the stimulus money that is going to black farmers
reparations or something else, Graham might as well get used to
talking about reparations, in general, for they are owed to those who
have suffered for centuries and have been left out of the
distribution of the wealth of the nation by its structural racism
after generations of being pushed to the margins, belittled, and
oppressed. The time has come for the tally of who owes what to whom.
He can cry all he wants about white farmers being left out of part of
the stimulus bill. They were not the victims of multi-generational
theft and bureaucratic flim-flam. Black farmers are the victims and
they are demanding recompense.
All
black Americans and their allies of every color, as good Americans,
will be demanding no less for all who have suffered and been deprived
by the same system that stole from black farmers. It’s time.
BlackCommentator.com Columnist, John
Funiciello, is a former newspaper reporter and labor organizer, who
lives in the Mohawk Valley of New York State. In addition to labor
work, he is organizing family farmers as they struggle to stay on the
land under enormous pressure from factory food producers and land
developers. Contact
Mr. Funiciello and BC.
|