On September
23rd, Democratic Party members of the Congressional Black Caucus held
a press conference discussing their outrage at the events that
transpired at the U.S. Border regarding Haitian immigrants seeking to
obtain political and residential asylum here in America. They also
made their disgust toward the Biden administration’s inept,
“leading from behind.” and “Johnny Come Lately”
handling of the catastrophe known as well. Most of you have probably
seen the aforementioned photograph and other similar images of White
men on horseback - armed, horse-mounted U.S. Border Patrol agents at
the Rio Grande in Texas, outfitted up and behaving sadistically.
Television
images of White guards, sneering and salivating as they maliciously
ran down Haitian immigrants with nooses and whips were nothing short
of appalling and abominable. The image of one agent seizing one
shoeless migrant, capturing him by the neck of his shirt is
particularly horrendous. The man’s face betrays an unmistakable
look of terror. The man struggles while trying to hang onto his bags.
The image is profoundly chilling and disturbing.
Inevitably,
social media was on fire earlier this week. Commentary ranged from
mildly outraged to remarks that I cannot print here. The White House
denounced
the graphic violence emanating from the pictures. Vice President
Kamala Harris weighed in referring to the episode as “horrific.”
The conflict culminated in the resignation of Diplomat Daniel Foote,
citing what he saw as the “depraved
immorality”
of the incident. The Department of Homeland Security launched an
investigation into the fiasco. Yes indeed, a political storm was
brewing.
Controversy
aside, what is just as distressing and outrageous is the vile,
retrograde history that it represents. For historians like me,
flashbacks of mid-19th century antebellum slave catchers, rounding
and roughing up slaves and treating them like chattel came to my
mind. Visions of a horrific chapter of American history seeped deep
into my psyche. To be sure, violence and other forms of untoward
behavior directed towards people of color in America, particularly
Black people, occurred long after the mid-19th century. Indeed, it
has manifested itself well up to the present day 21st century.
One
can only wonder, would a group of European immigrants have been
treated so callously? Indeed, think about it. Hypothetically
speaking, would a group of Canadian migrants from Quebec,
Saskatchewan, or British Columbia or other immigrants attempting to
cross the U.S. border have been attacked and disregarded with such
inhumane disdain? Let me save you some time and provide the answer
that most, if not all of you already know whether truthfully or
subliminally - HELL NO! They would not! End of story!
Predictably,
there have been certain segments of the right-wing
media
and right-wing trolls who have wasted no time going on a perverse
form of offense, brazenly attacking critics of the “fiasco at
the border” engaging in “blaming the victim”
tactics, accusing Haitian migrants for being targeted for attack, as
well as shamelessly and dishonestly running interference for the
border patrolmen, arguing that the agents were just doing their jobs
by aggressively cracking down on illegal immigration. This was hardly
the case! On the contrary, the only items the public saw them
“cracking” were whips on the backs of innocent and
terrified migrants!
Truth
be told, the Haitian migrant/Texas Border Patrol saga represents a
larger dynamic. The fact is that, since stepping foot on the shores
of America as immigrants, Black lives and bodies have been routinely
scrutinized, objectified, serialized and racialized. For many people,
Black bodies and Black people, children as well as adults, have never
been seen as fully human. All too often, we have been seen as men and
women who are largely primitive and invisible, largely denied any
degree of humane acknowledgment from mainstream society.
If
White people were routinely and randomly subjected to such wanton
violence, subjected to chronic levels of systemic and systematic
racism, frequently gunned down in the street by law enforcement
duplicative to the rate of Black and Hispanic people, there would be
calls for congressional hearings, mass public demonstrations and
cries of protests so loud that it would result in political suicide
for any politician who dared to ignore such a rallying cry and
decisive message. The George Floyd protests of 2020 would seem like a
picnic.
Of
course, there are police officers and other members of law
enforcement (arguably most) who are decent, law-abiding human beings
who manage to perform admirably doing a job that is undeniably
tedious and stressful. There also is a faction - one is too many - of
those with badges who shamelessly utilize the power of their
positions to misuse and abuse their authority. Right White denial,
political resistance and other factors notwithstanding, Black people
are human beings and deserve to be treated with as much respect and
dignity as any other group of people. Such sadistic behavior and
wicked disregard for people of color cannot continue.
BlackCommentator.com Guest
Commentator, Dr. Elwood Watson, Historian, public speaker, and
cultural critic is a professor at East Tennessee State University and
author of the recent book, Keepin' It Real: Essays on Race in
Contemporary America (University of Chicago Press), which is
available in paperback and on Kindle via Amazon and other major book
retailers. Contact Dr.Watson and BC.