This article originally appeared in Playahata.com.
I promised myself that I wouldn’t write about this.
But I’m frustrated and need to vent.
A few weeks ago, my piece
about Bill Cosby turned me into a lightning rod for both legitimate
critique and mean-spirited criticism. Perhaps the most surprising
and troubling response has come from Dr. Cosby himself.
The day that I published the piece, Dr. Cosby made
a call to the dean of my college. To be fair, the Coz explicitly
stated that he didn’t want the dean to do anything to me. Instead,
he wanted to express his concern that I was undermining his project.
Still, I’m sure that he understood the significance of the school’s
most famous and coveted alumnus/donor making a call about a young,
But it doesn’t stop there.
Over the next few days, I did a series of radio interviews
where I discussed the op-ed. In each interview, I reiterated both
my respect for Dr. Cosby and my critique of his “Call
Out” tour. I did a show in Atlanta with a Black conservative
who decided that “he would put me in my place.” Over the next hour,
I proceeded to punish him with reasoned arguments and strong examples.
A few minutes after the interview ended, I received
a call from a friend in Atlanta. He told me, “Go on the internet
and tune into the station. Bill Cosby just got on the radio and
he’s talking about you!”
I didn’t bother to ask how Bill Cosby, who I was sure
wasn’t in Atlanta, knew that I was on the radio discussing him.
Instead, I asked what he was saying about me. He replied, “He’s
calling you a liar and a hustler. He’s saying that you have a ‘hip-hop
website’ and that you can’t be trying to help Black people with
a ‘hip-hop website.’”
Words can’t convey the level of frustration that I
felt at that moment. Why couldn’t he have just called in while I
was on the air? I tuned back into the station to hear the end of
Cosby’s diatribe. By this point, he and the host (who cosigned everything
that Cosby said) were criticizing “the hustlers” who write about
hip-hop and critique him at the same time. He explicitly named Michael
Eric Dyson and me as two of the hustlers.
I tried to call into the station but I couldn’t get
on the guest line. My friend, who was on hold with the station,
called me back via three-way and offered to let me speak to Cosby
when it was his turn to speak. After a few minutes, I was on the
Me: Hello. Dr. Cosby this isn’t [my friend]. This
is actually Marc Lamont Hill. You were talking about me so I figured
I’d call back so that we could talk.
[clearly shocked and uncomfortable]: Yes?
Me: I don’t understand why you have to call me a liar
and a hustler. Why can’t my response be just as sincere and principled
Cosby never answered my question. Instead, he proceeded
to grill me about my job, my affiliations, and my “hip-hop web site.”
I attempted to explain the nature of my work–although he referenced
the site, I doubt that he actually read anything – and the substance
of my critique. Unfortunately, he insisted on talking over me and
trying to “son” me. Unintimidated, I continued to attempt to offer
my side of the story.
After 10 minutes or so, Cosby says “Mr. Hill. You’re
a smart man. You’re a good writer. You’ve called here twice. You’ve
had enough to say.”
Suddenly, I was being constructed as the pest who
was bothering HIM, when the truth was that he was calling in to
get at me! I then tried to explain how this show was a microcosm
of the larger problem with regard to Dr. Cosby excluding dissenting
voices from the public conversation.
Again, Dr. Cosby talked over me until the host intervened.
He said, “One at a time. After the break, we’ll let Professor Hill
respond and then Dr. Cosby can respond.” Cosby responded, “Mr. Hill
has said enough. He’s got a column. He’s called here twice. Let’s
take some calls.”
The show went to commercial and the producer said
to me, “Be patient. We’ll take 2 or 3 calls and get back to you.”
I waited patiently as Cosby took multiple calls and threw out a
few more disses. After all of the waiting calls were exhausted except
for me, the host says “After the break, we’ll be right back with
the next call.” Cosby responds, “I’m hungry, man. I want some dinner”
and hangs up.
Aggravated, I call back to the guest line and ask
what happened. The show’s host immediately jumps on the line and
says “I’m sorry. I totally forgot you were on the phone.”
Right. Two of the show’s guests, one of whom is a
worldwide celebrity, were arguing over a contentious issue and he
The host apologized and agreed to let me come back
on the air and give my closing comments. This time, however, he
was considerably hostile to me. Every time I tried to make a point,
he literally yelled over me (I guess having Dr. Cosby on the line
gave him some newfound confidence) and finally said “I gotta let
you go man.”
The next day, Cosby calls my college again. What did
he want? I won’t say in public. But one thing is for sure: he didn’t
call to speak to me.
Why am I writing this now? Because I’m learning a
valuable lesson about what happens when you offer unpopular social
criticism in public. Before this, I naively assumed that I could
speak the truth (as I see it) to power and power would respond fairly.
I fully expected to have to deal with people who don’t agree with
me. I never, however, fully appreciated the extent to which people
would use their power and privilege to silence alternate voices.
Lamont Hill, an
assistant professor of urban education at Temple University, is one of the youngest members of the growing body of “Hip-Hop Intellectuals”
in the country. His work, which covers topics such as hip-hop culture,
sexuality, education, and politics, has appeared in numerous journals,
magazines, books, and anthologies. He
can be contacted at firstname.lastname@example.org. or