A New York City jury found music
mogul Sean
“Diddy” Combs guilty of two counts of
transportation to engage in prostitution. On
July 2, the jurors acquitted him on three more
serious counts against him: one count of
racketeering and two counts of sex trafficking.
The split verdict saw Combs being exonerated of
the biggest charge, racketeering conspiracy. He
was found not guilty of the sex trafficking of
Casandra “Cassie” Ventura or of “Jane,” and
guilty of transportation to engage in
prostitution of both Casandra Ventura and
“Jane.”
Combs’s partial acquittal allows
him to avoid a potential sentence of life in
prison. Prosecutors initially said on Wednesday
that they would seek a maximum of 20 years in
prison combined on the two prostitution-related
counts. However, they said
in a letter later that day opposing Combs’s release
on bond that the sentencing guidelines range
from at least 51 to 63 months. Incarcerated
since his arrest in September, Combs had already
served nine months. Combs’s lawyers have stated
that under federal sentencing guidelines, he
would likely face about two years in prison. “We
fight on and we’re going to win,” commented
defense attorney Mark Agnifilo, “And we’re not
going to stop until he walks out of prison a
free man to his family.”
Arun Subramanian, the judge who
presided over the trial, denied Combs’s request
for release on bond ahead of sentencing, telling
the court Wednesday evening that it’s
“impossible” to show that Combs poses no danger
to the community. The judge set a tentative
sentencing date for October 3. The verdict
concluded a
several weeks-long saga involving Combs’s alleged
engagement in abusive tendencies toward
employees and romantic partners. Jurors
deliberated for roughly 13 hours across three
days, beginning on Monday.
The government alleged that
Combs used his power and wealth, as well as
violence and threats of blackmail, to coerce
women into complying and participating in what
were described as drug-induced sexual marathons
called “freak-offs.” These often involved one of
Combs’s girlfriends and male escorts. The trial
exposed Combs’s dysfunctional, toxic, personal
relationships, in which he perversely utilized
his power and connections as a rapacious and
unscrupulous businessman, hip-hop mogul, and
self-described “bad boy” over employees and
sexual partners - occasionally engaging in
sexual abuse.
From the trial’s outset, Combs’s
lawyers conceded their client engaged in
domestic violence - segments of wanton
physical abuse were witnessed on surveillance
video - but insisted that he’d never committed
sexual abuse of any kind and declared all of his
relationships as consensual. However, various
accusers, including Combs’s former girlfriend
and musician Casandra Ventura, contested
that framing in graphic testimony
depicting Combs as a violent employer and
romantic partner.
Throughout the trial, which
commenced on 12 May, the defense conceded
prior examples of domestic violence but disputed that any
coercion or sex trafficking occurred and
maintained that all
sexual activity was consensual and part of
a “swingers lifestyle.” They
argued that Combs was being wrongly prosecuted
for his private sexual peccadillos and
vehemently contested that any criminal
conspiracy existed.
Over several weeks, the
government called almost three dozen witnesses,
including two
of Combs’s former girlfriends, multiple former
employees and assistants, male
escorts, hotel staff, law enforcement
agents, and public figures such as rapper
Kid Cudi and singer
Dawn Richard. Combs did not testify. Both Casandra
Ventura and Jane recited raw, searing,
and emotional testimony alleging that Combs coerced
them into participating in the
frequent and sometimes days-long “freak-offs.”
Defense attorneys said Ventura
Fine was in essence a gold digger. This has been
a common trope pushed in previous notable,
high-level sexual abuse case defenses such as
those involving Harvey Weinstein, R. Kelly, Bill
Cosby, and Johnny Depp. Ventura filed a civil
suit against Combs in November 2023, when the
New York Adult Survivors Act gave sexual abuse
victims a short window to file civil claims even
after the statute of limitations had lapsed.
Combs settled
the case the next day for $20 million.
The verdict forces Combs to
reckon with accountability. Earlier, pushback to
his alleged mistreatment of employees was mostly
confined to internet-borne allegations and
speculation. This fact notwithstanding,
more than a few spokespeople against domestic
violence are understandably upset and
disappointed with a less than absolute total
conviction. They argue that the trial is another
instance of the legal system demonstrating it is
ill-equipped to handle the often complex
dynamics of intimate
partner violence. Supporters of Combs are eager
for him to resurrect his career and are
salivating for him to make a comeback.
It’s unclear what kind of time
Combs will serve, nonetheless, he’s facing a
staggering number of civil suits. Donald Trump
hasn’t ruled out pardoning
Diddy, and it is not inconceivable
that he might. Hopefully, he will recede into
the darkest, most remote corners of society.
However, as I see it, it is highly unlikely that
Sean “Puffy” Combs will be able to return to
even a fraction of the mega celebrity he once
enjoyed. This would be the most effective and
just verdict of all.
|
|