Karoline
Leavitt gave a
less than suitable response as to
what prompted President Trump to flippantly
insult a female reporter by calling her a
“piggy,” after he was asked a question about
Jeffrey Epstein. On Air Force One, Trump pointed
his finger in a
young female reporter’s, Catherine
Lucey’s, face and
snapped, “Quiet, piggy,” after
being asked about the trove of emails released
by the House Oversight Committee that revealed
Epstein, a child sex trafficker and convicted
pedophile, accusing Trump of
“knowing about the girls” involved in his
criminal operations. For the record, Trump
denies knowing any such information.
While not
directly explaining what the president meant,
Leavitt defended Trump and said he was elected
because of his “frankness.” Look, the president
is very frank and honest with everyone in this
room. You’ve all seen it yourself. You’ve all
experienced it yourselves,” Leavitt said. “And I
think it’s one of the many reasons the American
people reelected this president because of his
frankness.” Okay!
Lucey’s inquiry
to Donald
Trump aboard
Air Force One was certainly sensible as she was
inquiring about the release of the Epstein
files, a topic of considerable public interest.
Why had the president been stonewalling, she
asked, “if there’s nothing incriminating in the
files”.
Rather than
provide a reasonable answer, his response was
derelict, juvenile and sexist. He pointed
straight at Lucey and told her to stop doing her
job. “Quiet. Quiet, piggy,” said the president
of the United States. Yes, you read that
correctly. What was even more surprising, quite
frankly, more incredulous (at least to me) at
least from what I saw was what that none of her
fellow colleagues responded to defend her from
such a brazen attack. Very disturbing situation
to witness.
It should
not go without noting that Trump similarly
berated ABC
News and well regarded reporter Mary Bruce, who also
asked germane questions, about Khashoggi as well
as the Epstein files. “I think you are a
terrible reporter. It’s the way you ask these
questions,” he
said. He called
ABC a “crappy
company”
and said its license “should be taken away
from ABC because your news is so fake and it’s
so wrong.” This appears to be par for the
course.
To the
president’s most brazen supporters, such
verbally reductive banter is lauded and
applauded. To this crowd, such antics are just
one of many ways Trump utilizes his power and
position to “sock it to and own the supposedly
liberal elite” whom he has implored MAGA to
detest with intense, unbridled passion. To be
sure, Trump’s attacks on the media are hardly
new. He adamantly referred to the press as the
“enemy of the American people” shortly after first
taking office in 2017, an era
marked by his routine
attacks that
journalists and their work were “fake news.”
But for these
two most recent insults to happen back-to-back
is “chilling,” especially with the timing of
Trump’s meeting with bin Salman, the IWMF’s
Muñoz said.
Trump has an
even longer history of denigrating women more
broadly. This is reportedly not the first time
that he has used the word piggy to
describe a woman. Alicia Machado, the winner of
the 1996 Miss Universe pageant, has alleged that
Trump once
called her “Miss Piggy” and made
other demeaning comments about her weight. And
the president’s longtime feud with Rosie
O’Donnell has included much public sexism,
including Trump calling her a “big, fat pig” in 2006.
His
derogatory comments about female journalists
also date back, including in 2015, when he said
Fox
News host Megyn Kelly had
“blood coming out of her wherever.”
He has a
particular animosity toward and has often
clashed with
Black female reporters, targeting first-rate
journalist, Yamiche
Alcindor who
then covered the White House for the PBS
NewsHour, condemning her supposedly “nasty”
questions. Most recently, he called
Alcindor, who
currently works for NBC, “second rate” and
demanded that she, too, “be quiet.” He chastised
CNN journalist Abby
Philip for her supposedly “stupid”
questions. He
publicly called, April
Ryan, a
longtime, veteran White House reporter, “a
loser.” Crass and
blunt as his prior comments have been, even
“quiet, piggy” somehow takes such rancor to an
entirely new level of rudeness. Something that,
even for this president, was over the line.
Rancid commentary that should have been
confronted and challenged. A bridge too far, so
to speak.
One can only
envision what the reaction would have been if
the majority, or even a few members of the press
corps members railed back at Trump, challenged
and derided him for spewing such retrograde
language? Defending one of their colleagues? No
doubt that such a spectacle would have likely
reassured Catherine Lucey. Additionally, it
would have undoubtedly bolstered confidence
among one another. It was a much needed and
missed opportunity. Perhaps, they feared the
president’s personal wrath directed toward them,
the lack of access to future White House press
briefings etc...? Regardless, such a lack of
unity and vocal cowardice is alarming and does
not bode well for the future of a much desired
and needed vibrant, robust press corps,
including well after Trump leaves office.
|
|